james-logo

Understanding the Thin Skull Rule and its Relevance in Personal Injury Law

In personal injury law, the thin skull rule is a legal principle that may come into play if you or a loved one has a pre-existing condition or vulnerability. This rule ensures that the responsible parties are held accountable for the harm they caused, regardless of the victim’s susceptibility.

At James H. Brown and Associates, our team understands the complexities of the thin skull rule as it applies to personal injury law. Below, we will discuss the concept of the thin skull rule further, outlining its significance in personal injury law and highlighting the role that James H. Brown and Associates can play in helping victims navigate this challenging legal framework. Continue reading to learn more about how the thin skull rule applies to personal injury law.


What is the Thin Skull Rule?

The thin skull rule, otherwise known as the eggshell skull or frailty rule, is a legal doctrine that establishes a defendant as liable for the full extent of a plaintiff’s injuries, even if the plaintiff has an unusually fragile or vulnerable condition. To put it in more legal terms, a negligent party cannot use the plaintiff’s pre-existing conditions as a defence to mitigate or reduce their liability. This legal rule is rooted in the principle that defendants must take their victims as they find them, regardless of any pre-existing conditions that may increase the severity of the injuries sustained.


Application in Personal Injury Law:

The thin skull rule is particularly relevant in personal injury cases where a victim with a pre-existing condition suffers worsening or further harm due to the defendant’s negligence. Below are three common scenarios where this rule comes into play:

  • Pre-Existing Medical Conditions: If a person with a pre-existing medical condition (for example, a heart condition or immunodeficiency) is injured in a motor vehicle accident caused by someone else’s negligence, the defendant may be held fully responsible for any additional harm the accident caused. Under the thin skull rule, the defendant cannot argue that the plaintiff’s pre-existing condition made them more likely to get injured. 
  • Psychological or Emotional Vulnerabilities: The thin skull rule also includes psychological or emotional vulnerabilities. For instance, if a person diagnosed with PTSD is involved in a bicycle accident that aggravates their mental condition, the negligent driver may be liable for the resulting emotional distress and worsening of the plaintiff’s mental health. 
  • Elderly or Frail Individuals: Elderly or frail individuals may have a higher risk of sustaining severe injuries from accidents. The thin skull rule ensures that responsible parties are held fully accountable for the injuries suffered by these vulnerable individuals, even if their injuries are more severe due to their age or fragility. 


The Role of James H. Brown and Associates

Navigating personal injury cases in Alberta that involve the thin skull rule can be complex. That’s where experienced and award-winning personal injury lawyers, like those at James H. Brown and Associates, come in to help. Here’s how our team can assist with these personal injury claims:

  1. Case Evaluation: The personal injury lawyers at James H. Brown and Associates can assess the merits of your case and determine if the thin skull rule applies. Our team will thoroughly review your medical records and consult with medical experts to establish the causal relationship between the negligent party(ies) ‘s actions and your injuries, taking into account any pre-existing conditions. 
  2. Expert Testimony: James H. Brown and Associates’ team will utilize our network of medical experts and vocational professionals to attain expert testimony to support your personal injury claim. These experts can help demonstrate how the defendant’s negligence directly caused the worsening or aggravation of your pre-existing condition. 
  3. Building a Strong Case: A skilled personal injury lawyer, like those at James H. Brown and Associates, will assist in gathering all necessary evidence, including medical records, witness statements, and accident reconstruction reports. When building a solid and compelling case on your behalf, our team will ensure that the thin skull rule is appropriately applied, arguing that the defendant should be held responsible for the full extent of your injuries. 
  4. Negotiations and Advocacy: If the liable party(ies) ‘s insurance company offers a settlement, James H. Brown and Associates will negotiate on your behalf to ensure you attain just compensation for your injuries and other related damages. Our team is here to advocate for your rights and fight for the best possible outcome. 


Ready to Get Started on Your Personal Injury Claim?

The thin skull rule is an important legal doctrine that upholds the rights of victims with pre-existing conditions or vulnerabilities. It also ensures that the negligent parties are held accountable for the full extent of harm they caused, regardless of the victim’s unique circumstances.


At James H. Brown and Associates, our team is well-versed in Alberta’s personal injury laws. We can provide the legal expertise to help victims and their loved ones understand and navigate the implications of the thin skull rule. By employing James H. Brown and Associates’ expert team, you can rest assured that you have the best personal injury lawyers fighting for the compensation you deserve.

Contact us today to learn more about starting your personal injury claim.

related post